Clicky

Best Ice Fishing Boots – Reviews of Comfy Boots for Men and Women

If you’re looking for the best ice fishing boots, you’re in the right hands.

As we all know, fishing is no longer confined to summer only. It extends up to the winter months- when the ponds and lakes are completely covered with ice (giving birth to the practice of ice fishing).

Amazingly, the practice becomes popular every day, especially due to the fun it comes with.

And if you want to be fully prepared for this exciting experience, your first step should be securing a great pair of boots that will help keep your feet from freezing.

I want to make your next ice fishing day as exciting as possible. How? I dug deep into the market for the 10 most popular ice fishing shoes that fits your style and personal needs.

Let’s take a look at these boots:

Why Is A Pair of Ice Fishing Boots Necessary?

A good ice fishing journey starts with buying a real pair of ice fishing boots. I believe the best way to explain this phrase is picturing the challenges you’ll encounter in the ice fishing fields (and how ice fishing boots solves them).

Can you guess any of these challenges?

If you’ve been there before, then you know you’ve to deal with:

Ice

Obviously, ice will be your number one headache…and that means walking on slick surfaces that need a shoe with unbeatable traction to steady you all day long.

Luckily, ice fishing boots come with sturdy sole design, with deep tracks to offer you the extra grip that keeps you going.

Water

Water comes second. You’ve got to deal with…after all, ice is just water in frozen state. Now, if you don’t put on the right ice fishing shoes, you’ll truly get the full wrath of wet feet in winter. And trust me; your fishing day will end prematurely.

Again, you can count on the boots specially made for ice fishing. They come with a waterproof design to keep you from getting wet as much as possible.

Wind and cold

No winter is complete without some harsh winds and cold. For this reason, you want to ensure that the shoes you’re wearing do not permit the winds and hoses penetrate through your feet and give you those freezing moments that makes you almost immobile.

The best ice fishing boots comes fully insulated, with unique lacing system and good fit to shield you from the extreme conditions. This means comfort all day long.

Need we say more as to why you need to arm yourself with great ice fishing boots before hitting the ice fields?

Let’s shift pour focus to the 10 most all-time favorite ice fishing boots for men and women.

Our Best Ice Fishing Reviews:

1. Kamik Men's Greenbay 4 Cold-Weather Boot Review:

Kamik boots company (btw Kamik means “foot covering”) have been in existence for over 100 years, and have gathered enough expertise in designing a pair of ice boots to keep you warm in freezing cold conditions.

As one of their top-rated boots, the Kamik Men's Greenbay 4 Cold-Weather Boot is able to keep you warm and comfortable in the harshest ice fishing conditions you can imagine (in fact, it can withstand extreme temperature of up to -40!).

One of the Kamik’s secrets to making this boot a favorite among anglers is injecting it with super-waterproof capabilities. The shoe features a flexible Duration 600 nylon upper to keep ice/snow totally locked out of your feet.

In addition to waterproofing, the nylon shell has highly durable and lightweight properties, which means a great service for years to come.

The high-tech boot from Kamik also comes with a removable felt liner that work hand in hand with the lace-lock snow collar to keep your feet warm (and comfortable) in and out. As I told you earlier, the shoe is rated at -40 Fahrenheit.

The mid-foot adjustable Velcro closure strap gives you a snug fit that further facilitates comfort…and the rubber outsole with thick threads gives you all the traction you need to safely walk on the slipper icy surfaces.

​Highlighted Features:

  • Textile construction
  • Made in the USA
  • Synthetic sole
  • Shaft measures about 13" from arch
  • Waterproof upper
  • Removable 8m, thermal-guard lining
  • Hook and look strap
  • Drawstring at the top line

2. The Original MuckBoots Adult Arctic Sport Boot Review:

The second ice fishing boots review goes to the Original MuckBoots Adult Arctic Sport Boot. It began in 1999 when the Original MuckBoots Company set to build the most comfortable, high-performance ice boots on the market.

And this gave birth to this particular shoe which comes suited to keep you warm and safe in the messy and severe ice fishing conditions.

As the signature shoe for MuckBoots, these shoes offers you are the warmest of the warmest bots out there. They’re designed to keep you warm in the most extreme conditions falling in the range -40° F to 60°F.

Isn’t this is the boot every man and woman angler would want to rock in when fishing in the ice.

Similar to our previous model, this boot also comes with a 100% waterproof design from the rubber sole all the way up. This ensures that water and ice do not easily find their way into your feet, which can freeze your feet and affect your fishing activities.

The grippy sole gives you the extra traction you need when walking on the slippery ice surfaces. It does this by firmly gripping you on the surface, giving you the stability you need to enjoy fishing in ice.

The highly popular boot comes with a black color and is available in a wide range of sizes for both men and women (refer to the sizing manual for more details) to meet your personal needs.

​Highlighted Features:

  • Rubber and fabric design
  • Rubber sole
  • Shaft measurements: 14.5” from arch
  • Heel measurements: 1.25”
  • Added toe protection with wrap-up rubber
  • Platform measurements: 0.75”
  • Boot opening measurements: 15.5” around
  • Comfort range: -40° F to 60°F
  • 2mm underlay thermal foam in the instep area promotes additional warmth
  • 100% waterproof, flexible and lightweight boot
  • Waterproof all the way up

3. Korkers RockTrax Fly Fishing Overshoe Carbide 28 Spikes Cleats Review:

Korkers RockTrax Fly Fishing Overshoe stands as one of the most affordable ice fishing boots on the market right now. So, if you’re on a budget, this is the deal for you.

But its low pricing doesn’t stop it from giving you the performance associated with an ice fishing boot. It has a pretty unique design- a versatile cleated shoe that provides you with a truly unique performance.

One of the reasons why expert an upcoming fishermen keep going for this model is its exceptional traction! It comes with a whopping 28 tractions in each pair (place under heel, toe, and ball of foot) to give you a high-level traction that keep you moving safely and easily on the slick ice terrain.

As if that’s not enough, it also feature up to 24 receptacles where you can fit custom studs for added traction.

Putting on or getting off the shoes has been made easy and fast with the quick release buckle and strap system. According to most fishermen, this is way better than the traditional lacing method that takes you years to do.

Because of the secure fit molded rubber walls at the heel, toe, and the sides, you’re sure to get a snug fit all day long.

​Highlighted Features:

  • Synthetic and rubber construction
  • Traction 28 spikes per pair, under heel, toe, and ball of foot
  • Customizable 24 additional spike receptacles for custom studs placement
  • Easy on/off quick release buckle and strap system for getting you and out of cleats easily
  • Secure fit molded rubber walls at heel, toe, and side for secure fit
  • Durable push-through carbide spikes placed under heel, toe, and ball of foot

4. Guide Gear Men's Monolithic Waterproof Insulated Hunting Boots Review:

The 4th spot goes to the Guide Gear Men's Monolithic Waterproof Insulated Hunting Boots. True to what its manufacturers claims, this is pair of ultra W-A-R-M boots that “heats up” your feet and lets you walk comfortably in the most extreme weather conditions.

How it keep your feet warm in sub-zero temps? Well, it features a super insulation job of 2,400g Thinsulate that acts as a bigtime barrier to cold. This means that your feet will remain tasty, so you can direct al your focus to your fishing activities.

In terms of durability, these shoes will never disappoint you. They’re constructed from the suede leather plus 900-D nylon uppers. This guarantees you and extend shoe lifespan. Besides, it makes the shoe completely waterproof from the bottom all the way up.

Other factors that help keep your feet dry and comfortable include the removable EVA foam insole, breathable shoe membrane, moisture-wicking mesh lining, padded collar and tongue, and ¾-gusseted tongue that keeps off water and debris.

​Highlighted Features:

  • Waterproof, breathable membrane
  • Mossy Oak color
  • Thinsulate insulation
  • 100% waterproof boots
  • Super-grip rubber outsole
  • Removable mesh-lined EVA foam for added comfort
  • Moisture-wicking mesh lining
  • Padded tongue, color

5. Baffin Men's Selkirk Snow Boot Review:

Baffin footwear has been in the shoe making game for over 25 years. Unlike their competitors, they combine the leading molding technology plus foam-based inner boot system to produce hybrid, high-performance ice fishing boots.

The Baffin Men's Selkirk Snow Boot is one such hybrid- ready to give you extreme warmth, comfort and fit.

The ice boot boasts of the unrivaled 8-layer combination of materials used in its construction. The fact that these material are capable of making you feel warm at the most extreme temperatures (-94F) make them one of the most preferred models out there.

Something else that differentiates these shoes from their rivals is how the sole as well as midsole comes molded into the base in a continuous process. This ensures that you enjoy superior warmth and protection.

Baffin shoes are the way to go if you want to enjoy the ultimate functionality and durability

​Highlighted Features:

  • Synthetic
  • Synthetic sole
  • Shaft measures about 13” from arch
  • Heel measures about 1.25.”
  • Platform measures around 1.25.”
  • Knee-high design, with drawstring at the opening
  • Adjustable calf strap
  • Adjustable ankle strap with hook-and-loop closure

6. Korkers CastTrax Cleated Overshoe Review:

We previously reviewed a top-quality ice fishing boot from the Korkers. Luckily, the brand has another top-quality shoe in their line- the CastTrax Cleated Overshoe which comes fully optimized for an exceptional performance on mossy oak, rock, ice/snow and slick terrains.

Just like the other Korkers model, this overshoe offers you surefire traction that enables you to walk on the slippery ice/snow surfaces. This is made possible by the presence of 36 durable threaded carbide spikes in each pair.

Add to the fact that you can easily replace these spikes at any time and you got a never-ending traction! And as a generous gesture, the manufacturer includes up to 10 FREE carbide spikes in the package.

The snow boot also comes with molded rubber walls at strategic points- on the heels, toes and the sides. This does an excellent job at making the shoe snugly fit on your feet all-day long.

Like all the others boots that make up our list of the best boots for ice fishing, this shoe comes 100% waterproof capable, with 600 gram Thinsulate to keep your feet warm and comfortable.

​Highlighted Features:

  • Quick release buckle and strap system allows easy on/off
  • 36 durable and replaceable threaded carbide spikes per pair
  • Molded rubber walls for secure fit
  • Carbide spike pattern and aggressive rubber lug team up for excellent traction
  • 10 additional carbide replacement spikes plus 1 buckle
  • Black/Moonrock color

7. Kamik Men's Canuck Cold Weather Boot Review:

Kamik makes a comeback on our list, this time with the Men's Canuck Cold Weather Boot. This is a fabric boot with rubber outsole and features drawstrings instead of the standard lacing.

They’re reactive praises from the anglers for their excellent traction and ability to take on/off easily.

Because the boots are made from 100-D nylon, they’re 100% waterproof in all icy conditions. The adjustable opening also works with nylon shell to ensure moisture does not easily get into the shoes (and into your feet), giving you bone-dry performance for the entire day you’ll spend out there.

The outsole comes with deep treads, which makes the shoe even more suitable for ice fishing. That is, they’re sure to give you more traction that helps you walk with ease on the slippery ice/snowy surfaces.

However, I advise you to carefully consult the sizing manual to ensure you buy the right fit for you.

​Highlighted Features:

  • Fabric
  • Rubber sole
  • Knee-high ice fishing boot
  • 100-Denier waterproof nylon with rubber shell at the foot
  • Bungee cords at ankle and opening
  • Embroidered logo at the side of the boot
  • Removable 8mm Zylex liner
  • Slip resistant tread

8. Baffin Men's Wolf Snow Boot Review:

We’re back to Baffin! This Baffin Men's Wolf Snow Boot belongs to the Baffin Reaction Series. That means it has a lighter, more technical design which suits it for ice fishing and any other outdoor activities you can think of- especially in the deep snow. The end of goal of the boot is to keep your feet comfortable and protected.

The Wolf Snow boots do not differ much compared to the Baffin model we discussed earlier. For instance, they feature a midsole and sole molded to the base in a continuous process for total protection and warmth, synthetic sole, drawstring collar, 7-layer removable insulated inner boot system, among other features standard in the other Baffin models.

​Highlighted Features:

  • Leather and textile
  • Synthetic sole
  • Shaft measures approx. 11” from the arch
  • Padded ice boots, with dual buckle straps around the shaft
  • Drawstring collar
  • EVA midsole
  • 7-layer removable insulated inner boot system
  • Black/Pewter

9. Baffin Men's Arctic Winter Boot Review:

Baffin once more! The Men's Arctic Winter Boot is also part of the Baffin Reaction Series, and a popular pick for anglers all over the US. This means that it comes with a lightweight, technical design that makes it ideal for all your ice fishing activities in the harshest and most extreme conditions out there.

In terms of construction, the boots uppers are made from the double weave 900-Denier nylon which gives the boot a stronger and more flexible look and feel than its rivals.

Like all its cousins from Baffins, it boasts of a7-layer inner boot system with a comfort rating of the -40F/-40C range. This is sure to keep your feet warm all day as you fully concentrated n catching more fish in the ice.

The boot is also 100% waterproof, plus it features drawstring collar which locks out snow incursion. The thick, grippy sole guarantees you a firm footing over the slippery wintery terrains.

​Highlighted Features:

  • 900-D nylon
  • Made in the USA
  • Rubber sole
  • Rugged textile construction; rated at -40F/-40C
  • 7-layer removable, insulated inner boot system
  • Bungee snow collar plus ankle fit

10. Kamik Women's Greenbay4 Boot Review:

Lastly, we have a great pick for the women anglers in the house straight from Kamik! The Women's Greenbay4 Boot fits the definition of a high-tech ice fishing boot designed to give you superior comfort, the best fit, and unbeatable traction on the slick ice and snow terrains.

The boot is constructed using lightweight, but highly durable and waterproof nylon shell that assures you of great services for longer periods of time.

To keep your feet feeling warm in the extreme conditions, the boot features a removable Thinsulate foam liner. And for even more warmth all-day long, you can count on the lace-lock collar.

As a matter of fact, the shoes boasts of a comfort rating of -40F, so it can keep you comfortable in the adverse conditions associated with ice fishing.

All fisherwomen who have won these boots before are proud of its snug fit. The manufacturer explain the reason behind this fit as the mid-foot adjustable Velcro closure strap. Remember the more fitting your shoe is, the more comfortable you’ll feel.

And oh! Don’t forget its thick threaded rubber outsole that gives you lots of traction to enable you to walk comfortably on the slippery ice and snow terrains.

If you’re looking for the womens ice fishing boots, you’ll never regret investing in the Kamik Women's Greenbay4 Boot!

​Highlighted Features:

  • Textile
  • Made in the USA
  • Rubber sole
  • Shaft measures around 12” from arch
  • Heel measures around 1¼”
  • Platform measures around12”
  • Boot opening measures about 15” around
  • Waterproof boot with drawstring closure at shaft
  • Hook and loop strap at ankle

What To Look For Before Getting Ice Fishing Boots?

Before you head to the market to buy yourself a pair of the best boots for ice, make sure you carry the following checklist with you:

Waterproof

Remember what we said earlier about water? Well, it’s one of the challenges you’ll have to deal with whenever you’re ice fishing.

Luckily, you can cheat this problem given that most of the ice fishing boots put there come with a waterproof design. That is, they feature rubber base attached to their heavy-duty liner, nylon, or other high-strength materials. Their upper section also come pre-treated to easily water.

Before you buy a boot that you wish to use for ice fishing, be sure to check if it’s capable of withstanding waters and keep your feet dry.

Traction

Another important feature that defines a shoe truly constructed for ice fishing is traction.

As you know, ice and snow tend to be highly slippery. Walking on them can, therefore, be dangerous, especially when your boots do not offer you the right amount of traction.

I know you want to end your day in the ice fishing fields on a happy note, without cases of the notorious backslides. So, id advice you to pay particular attention to the sole design of that shoe you intend to purchase.

The ideal boot for walking on ice should feature spikes (or deep tracts) that firmly grips you on the surfaces when walking.

Insulation

Insulation should also play a central in the type of ice fishing boots you buy. We can’t deny the fact that we also need our feet to feel extremely comfortable when inside those boots.

And one way to guarantee that warmth and comfort is buying boots with an excellent insulation job. Rubber and synthetic materials are known as the top performance when it comes to insulation and total comfort. Additional materials include thinsulate, heetseeker, zylex, primaloft, opti-warm, and wool felt.

Which insulation material has been used in the shoe you’re planning to buy?

Size

Though the size factor is self-explanatory, I’d like to explain something about it…

Most fishermen prefer wearing their winter boots with some thick socks. If you plant to do the same, then be sure to look for a size that comfortably accommodate the addition socks layer as well, without compromising the shoe fit.

Durability

As you move from one shoe to another in the stores, you’ll quickly note that different shoes come with various designs.

The trick here is to pick a model from a recognized, made of heavy-duty materials, and capable of withstanding the most extreme outdoor conditions and elements- particular snow and ice.

Ignore this factor, and you’ll end up with boots that are highly vulnerable to extreme conditions; a waste of your cash.

Lightweight Design

Lastly, look for a pair of boots made from light materials. This ensures their overall weight is as light as a feather. The last thing you want in your ice fishing is a pair of heavy boots that makes your legs grow tired with every step you make.

This helps improve your overall comfort, no doubt!

Ice Fishing Boots vs Ordinary Boots

It’s surprising how a high number of people can’t tell the difference between ice fishing and regular boots.

But there exists a huge difference between the two, with both models intended for different functions.

Let’s get to understand the two types of boots better:

Both boot models share a similarity in that they’re both designed to keep your foot warm and comfortable in cold weather conditions (when used in their intended situations).

Ice Fishing Boots

Talking of the ice fishing boots, they’re designed for use in heavy snow/ice conditions. For this reason, they come with a unique design where they feature a rubber bottom to keep water from reaching your feet.

Their upper part usually extend above the ankle to give enough room for the snow gaiter integrated into the boot, offer additional warmth, and facilitate ankle support.

Being a specialty boot designed to help keep you warm and protected, the shoe has a price to pay. That is, they feel bulkier and heavier than the normal boots.

In addition to ice fishing, you can put on these boots if you’re involved in any other outdoor activities during winter, e.g. camping trips, hunting, skiing, etc.

Ordinary Boots

Regular boots, on the contrary, are more like “general use” models. And just like the ice boots, they come with some insulation job to keep your feet warm and comfortable in the extreme weathers.

Though these models also show some water repelling abilities, their waterproof capabilities are way below those of ice fishing boots. In other terms, if you decide to wear regular boots to an ice fishing trip, you’ll soon have to deal with ice and water getting into your feet through the lower feet and upper section.

This calls for a tough task at the end of the day as you try to clean the winter boots.

That being said, you should limit using your pair of ordinary boots (or winter boots) in normal daily activities only- like commuting, shoveling drives/sidewalks, driving, shopping, etc.

Final Verdict

I said it earlier- the journey of a great day in ice fishing fields start with buying the best ice fishing boots. As you slosh water and ice and get exposed to extreme conditions out there for hours, you’ll absolutely need to protect your feet, keep them warm and comfortable.

Nothing does this better than the 10 pairs of ice fishing boots I’ve just reviewed for you above. Likewise, you can follow our buying guide to end up with the coolest women/mens ice fishing boots ice fishing boots that will make your ice fishing more fun.

Enjoy!

  • July 27, 2017
  • Ice
Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: